ARTIST  |  ART  |  BIZ  |  BUZZ
separator
Browse  |  View Large  |  View @ Flickr
Consultation  |  Service  |  Sign Up  |  cartnew Cart
photograph RightTop
Shadow_BottomLeft Shadow_BottomRight
previous | 9 | next

reduced

homeless woman, san francisco, november 2006

----------

Loading...

If edition information does not appear here automatically, please select below.

----------

 

...or select a different edition:

 
Pages: | More @ Flickr
  • faith.jpg
  • indelible.jpg
  • sadie.jpg
  • death.jpg
  • ontheroad.jpg
  • camping.jpg
  • streetwise.jpg
  • drifter.jpg
  • reduced.jpg
  • verybad.jpg
  • kids.jpg
  • awaken.jpg
  • itwasnt.jpg
  • beautiful.jpg
  • forgiveness.jpg
  • running.jpg
  • onlything.jpg
  • cowboy.jpg
  • beloved.jpg
  • longshoreman.jpg
  • luckless.jpg
  • intheglare.jpg
  • disturbance.jpg
  • something.jpg
  • gods.jpg
  • dexter.jpg
  • sunday.jpg
  • spring.jpg
  • american.jpg
  • gabriel.jpg
  • stained.jpg
  • streetsixteen.jpg
  • hard.jpg
  • motherless.jpg
  • turk.jpg
  • still.jpg
  • beavis.jpg
  • hardtimes.jpg
  • expatriot.jpg
  • noalt.jpg
  • springrain.jpg
  • tuesday.jpg
  • elizabeth.jpg
  • neverland.jpg
  • waiting.jpg
  • weathered.jpg
  • imsorry.jpg
  • father.jpg
  • salvation.jpg
  • addicted.jpg
  • life.jpg
  • lord.jpg
  • circus.jpg
  • standout.jpg
  • beingthere.jpg
  • freight.jpg
  • skyler.jpg
  • wide.jpg
  • where.jpg
  • northern.jpg
  • unintended.jpg
  • newlife.jpg
  • jasmine.jpg
  • repair.jpg
  • oldgrowth.jpg
  • streetfight.jpg
  • care.jpg
  • crash.jpg
  • cut.jpg
  • keeping.jpg
  • everywhere.jpg
  • lifepoetic.jpg
  • candle.jpg
  • amigo.jpg
  • far.jpg
  • lost.jpg
  • jack.jpg
  • grit.jpg
  • tiempo.jpg
  • halo.jpg
  • otis.jpg
  • inbetween.jpg
  • twins.jpg
  • chinatown.jpg
  • brotherhood.jpg
  • blues.jpg
  • walk.jpg

homeless rebecca from detroit. rebecca doesn't fit. as though she's not where she's supposed to be. i see her as i pass. she is almost ghostly. she sways and bends like the only tree on a hill; unprotected. she seems resigned to a losing battle.

she is panhandling as i pass. or she is praying or mourning. but she is not seen. i turn the corner and watch her for a moment. she grimaces her mouth as though swallowing some new resignation and moves away from the season's passing throng; in my direction, but floating by. i seem to snap a trance when i say hello.

she's been homeless since 1998. she sleeps sometimes in shelters. but says there's not enough beds for women. the men have many more. she went to the shelter this afternoon to put her name in for a bed this evening. there's a lottery, and she didn't get one.

says she has no family and no children. she's the only one. but she has one girlfriend who got a place from the city finally after years. says she's trying to stay there with her friend tonight, if she can make up the guest fee. she's about a third of the way. it's been cold and she clearly doesn't want to be on the street tonight.

she was an accountant not so long back. she had a good job. she worked for kgo. but in '98, they were downsizing her group and she was let go. she thought she'd get another job easy. but she never did. they all wanted someone younger. and now she's 54, and says it's too late for her.

(11/12/06)

151 Flickr comments:

DanCgn says:
 Hi, I'm an admin for a group called American Melancholy, and we'd love to have this added to the group!

...posted 7/6/2010 9:00:43 AM

 
.Betina. says:
 Your portraits are superb. Their stories bring them to life. Incredible photojournalism.
--
Seen on your photo stream. (?)

...posted 6/9/2010 9:00:33 PM

 
SkyReiter says:
 "...she had a good job...", "...downsizing...", " thought she'd get another job easy. but she never did."

How many more people have gone through this scenario in the last year?

Looking at Tom's pictures we can all pick out people whose situations closely mirror our own, and see where a single incident or wrong decision could take us.

...posted 1/17/2010 5:25:23 PM

 
NewFeenix says:
 Stunning. A truly captivating and distilling image; your portraits are beyond amazing - I've spent quite some time no reading through many of the biopics you've furnished with each image, and find myself getting more and more involved with each newly discovered character :)

...posted 1/14/2010 12:10:54 AM

 
DigitalK says:
 the photo tells the story, you dont have to.

...posted 10/12/2009 4:56:55 PM

 
Ray maï says:
 Breathtaking

...posted 9/4/2009 10:19:21 AM

 
decembre says:
 Hi, I'm an admin for a group called Portrait★Faces★Open Minded, and we'd love to have this added to the group!


--
Seen next to a fellow photo of the group "Portrait★Faces". (?)

...posted 5/31/2009 7:29:46 PM

 
david∆richardson says:
 fantastic!

...posted 5/7/2009 5:05:57 PM

 
allenwrinwick says:
 Thank you for bringing this social issue to our attention. I have been where she is...I know the horrors of life on the streets, where one becomes "invisible" to the passers by. I am 46 years old and because someone saw my plight, I am working my way back to rejoin society. My thoughts and prayers go out to this person. Again I thank you for your compassion.

...posted 5/12/2008 12:24:23 AM

 
cady lady says:
 you are amazing! i have never seen so many gorgeous portrait, and beautiful people. keep up this wonderful work...it's really inspiring to me.

...posted 4/22/2008 6:03:18 AM

 
boxer rescue says:
 Hi, I'm an admin for a group called The Sanatorium Under The Sign Of The Hourglass, and we'd love to have your photo added to the group.

...posted 3/31/2008 3:51:28 AM

 
Gianni Mazzarelli says:
 Hi, I'm an admin for a group called Kubrick's Look (tag: KubricksLook), and we'd love to have your photo added to the group.

...posted 2/21/2008 3:05:43 AM

 
Bruce Lemons says:
 Haunting! Beautiful work!

...posted 11/2/2007 4:22:49 AM

 
[boti] says:
 very strong picture!

...posted 10/15/2007 9:57:09 PM

 
decembre says:
 ♥Thank you too for your post in
"Portrait★Faces"
Continue !

--
Seen in someone's favorites. (?)

...posted 8/6/2007 9:06:30 PM

 
Rev. Xanatos Satanicos Bombasticos (ClintJCL) says:
 Adam Burleigh, that was awesome.

...posted 6/9/2007 10:17:57 PM

 
palmettoart says:
 Just discovered your work - you have Dorothea Lange's eye, and Munch's artistry. Absolutely beautiful.

...posted 6/9/2007 5:23:03 PM

 
Adam Burleigh says:
 hey man, i love your photography. i did a study painting of this photo, the painting is here: img363.imageshack.us/img363/5516/sadwomanuu1.jpg

i'd love to do more from your work , what do you think?

i would love to warp / caricature the faces in other's i do. my email is adamburleigh at yahoo dot co dot uk.

thanks.

...posted 6/9/2007 1:26:33 AM

 
leVan_i says:
 i'm speechless... any word looses its sense....
marvellous!!!

...posted 5/1/2007 9:40:50 PM

 
nicolas levesque says:
 shit man, theres too much comentarys on this, oscar wilde told in a letter once, "the mistery of the world is in the visible, not in the invisible" i read that in susan sontag's book, " against interpretation" check it out!!!!!
chao and take care, dont stop what your doing, i love your images!!!!

...posted 4/30/2007 1:51:20 AM

 
Bemused Capybara says:
 i love love love the fact that you add a text to your portraits. it makes them all the more powerful, all the more mind blowing, all the more "you". i've said it before, and i'll say it again, i love your work.
an amazing portrait, of a sad woman. you've captured her perfectly.

...posted 4/20/2007 9:08:52 PM

 
TriggerImage says:
 An amazing series of portraits.

...posted 4/16/2007 9:27:05 AM

 
Olive Bordello says:
 unbelievable.

...posted 4/15/2007 8:51:29 AM

 
Wikdmessenger says:
 Skrik

...posted 4/14/2007 12:49:25 PM

 
artOtek says:
 This amazing one reminds me of the Scream by Edvard Munch! I'm speechless...

...posted 3/28/2007 8:53:20 AM

 
atwose says:
 incredible

...posted 3/23/2007 11:08:55 AM

 
*¨¨¨.:Salmonella_ja! pintó un White_cat:.¨¨* says:
 Hi, I'm an admin for a group called FOTOS INCREIBLES, and we'd love to have your photo added to the group.

...posted 3/19/2007 2:41:49 PM

 
MeekoMommy says:
 It's unbelievable that she is only 14 years older than myself and looks 30 years older!!!!

I love your pieces... It really brings compassion and humility to the forefront!

...posted 3/15/2007 11:46:34 PM

 
Engin Korkmaz says:
 your works are utterly amazing. i love all your portraits..

...posted 3/13/2007 3:24:44 PM

 
girl_least_likely_to says:
 So intense!!

...posted 3/6/2007 2:01:11 PM

 
Lady Vervaine says:
 My God, Stoneth. You always stop me dead in my tracks. Extraordinary work, as ever.

...posted 2/28/2007 10:20:49 PM

 
Joy is a Joy says:
 i saw her on muni this morning.

...posted 2/8/2007 4:07:52 PM

 
Rev. Xanatos Satanicos Bombasticos (ClintJCL) says:
 And of course, she is not counted in unemployment statistics because they only count new employment.

So those that say globalization doesn't affect jobs can sneer with their false statistics -- this woman never lost her job because she's not unemployed because she's not drawing unemployment statistics.

Don't let the globalists doublethink convince you.

...posted 2/5/2007 5:29:14 PM

 
Victoria Frigerio/ Photography says:
 What a sad story.
I feel powerless.
Good to have people like you to show what's going on out there.

btw, superb shot.;)

...posted 2/2/2007 10:47:27 PM

 
daniellajaeger says:
 like everyone said, reminds me of the scream right away, cool shot

...posted 1/10/2007 5:55:57 PM

 
Bod8kin says:
 This photo and story has just changed the way I do photography. Heretofore I was in pursuit of beauty. But there is a stranger, deeper beauty in that shot that is so relevant to us all. The challenge now is to seek out what I (by nature) recoil from and search for the warmth and beauty beyond the surface of skin. But you have been doing that all along. Society needs more people like you!

...posted 1/5/2007 6:58:17 PM

 
mojlogin says:
 fantastic!!
very expressive!!
beautiful portrait!!

...posted 1/4/2007 9:56:53 AM

 
iamnona says:
 not unlike so many stories told by these poor & beautiful people, but so sad nonetheless~ it is certainly a perspective that should be taken on by us all, who think that it could never happen to us...you can't always predict the future nor count on it to be a saving grace~ i'm sure there are those that may actually "like" this lifestyle- i find it more believable that it was simply unavoidable to most, however~ a haunting image, as always~

...posted 1/3/2007 12:36:10 PM

 
montse & ferran travelers says:
 Tan tristes històries com impressionants fotografies... La meva sincera enhorabona pel treball. Barcelona (Catalunya).

Tan tristes son las historias como impactantes tus fotos... Mi más sincera enhorabuena por el trabajo. Barcelona (Cataluña)

So sad are stories as impressive your photos… My more sincere congratulations by your portrait. Barcelona (Catalonia)

...posted 12/19/2006 1:49:25 PM

 
craig moreschini says:
 Wow, talk about amazing!

...posted 12/17/2006 11:48:32 PM

 
sunburnsideup says:
 Moving story...I can't believe that people actually become homeless as a result of downsizing. Age discrimination, too. What a cruel world we live in...I'm glad there are concerned and compassionate people like you.

...posted 12/17/2006 4:50:59 PM

 
muskva says:
 online gallery finally - wow!

...posted 12/17/2006 4:19:53 PM

 
SkyShaper says:
 your the master

...posted 12/15/2006 5:33:50 AM

 
simurg(parm..) says:
 Great!!!

...posted 12/14/2006 11:47:28 AM

 
*RICCIO "il colore del ricordo inganna" says:
 your pictures are always wonderful....

THIS IS GREAT!

...posted 12/14/2006 9:45:08 AM

 
Hawkeye39 says:
 Record their lives so that something other than memories of those homeless people will be left behind....put their photos everywhere so that people can't ignore them....remind people that someday this too could be you.

...posted 12/14/2006 2:31:17 AM

 
jinxmcc says:
 There's a question raised implicitly in some of the discussion here which wasn't acknowledged, and it's this: does a person who makes an effort to help solve a social problem lose all credibility --- and honor --- if he/she does not take a vow of poverty, receive no payment (or at best poverty wages) for the work done?

For those who want to ignore the social problem, there's an advantage in having a rule like that, because --- of the few people who might tackle social problems --- many will be eliminated by a demand that they and their families live in poverty while they do so.

Obviously I'm arguing that it's appropriate for the social worker, or photographer, to receive reasonable remuneration for their hard and trying work and their talent.

I do entirely agree that photography subjects should be asked permission and given as clear as possible an understanding of what will be done with the images taken of them. And I would think it strange and inappropriate if the artist made a fortune and used none of it to help fiscally with the basic problem.
I feel confident that would not be likely with our deeply empathetic friend Tom --- I am more concerned that he gives too much of himself, than too little.

...posted 12/13/2006 10:15:21 PM

 
petebeck says:
 there are few photos that will bring me to a dead stop like this one has this morning. the hopelessness in her face will be clinging to me all day today. thank you for such a wonderful and powerful image.

...posted 12/13/2006 4:58:37 PM

 
Kumasan says:
 my god

...posted 12/3/2006 6:23:44 AM

 
Bellechique says:
 these people are so much part of society

...posted 11/28/2006 10:42:34 PM

 
n.kiefer says:
 love the photo.

love the story...

but it is tough to look at...

any more of her?

...posted 11/28/2006 9:12:38 PM

 
Plemon Studios says:
 A haunting image, I wish I could see her entire head. Love it.

...posted 11/28/2006 6:21:59 PM

 
wd9hot says:
 Thanks Stoneth for sharing, And for the gentle tug that you give to your viewers that we are all indeed unique souls with needs.

...posted 11/28/2006 9:35:13 AM

 
*s_a_m* says:
 bravo...for capturing humanity...for telling their stories.

...posted 11/27/2006 9:40:36 PM

 
François Vassivière § says:
 You're a master § Equivalent of Goya §

...posted 11/27/2006 7:36:21 PM

 
waking_dream says:
 very powerful shot

...posted 11/25/2006 7:36:06 AM

 
exhibitj says:
 Great work, Tomas.
This photo generated quite abit of discussion on the intents of social documentary photographers and the state of poverty/homelessness in USA. Riveting discussions and lively responses to each of them.

I see the beginning of the change you intend to bring about here.

...posted 11/23/2006 2:42:52 AM

 
nathalie booth says:
 I see an old homeless man everyday in Oakland, everyday he is a little less himself, more dirty (In a year he has not changed clothes nor seems to have had a bath), under fed, crippled, he is dying little by little and nobody seems to care, it is as if people were waiting for him to die... I don't understand. So much more seems to be done for dogs...

Are there no social services to take care of people like this?
Your portrait is so well captured

...posted 11/22/2006 9:54:55 PM

 
candansusoy says:
 woww great! congrats!

...posted 11/22/2006 9:02:54 PM

 
gregpphoto says:
 This is one the best photographs ive ever seen. Its disgusting. Its inhumane. Seeing the pain these people feel through just one photograph. If only the entire world could see these photos, maybe there wouldnt be any homeless people left to photograph.

...posted 11/22/2006 8:30:08 PM

 
@Leo@ says:
 sad story....
amazing pic.

...posted 11/22/2006 4:26:12 AM

 
Simontacchi says:
 Badass!!

...posted 11/21/2006 12:53:24 AM

 
Mike Ross says:
 My God.

...posted 11/20/2006 5:58:32 PM

 
Paul Turgeon says:
 First time viewer. Your photos and stories are very moving. Thanks for sharing them.

...posted 11/19/2006 11:05:04 PM

 
dlemieux says:
 amazing portrait....haunting...heartwrenching story...

...posted 11/19/2006 7:23:57 PM

 
DerrickT says:
 !!!!!!!!!!!!!

...posted 11/19/2006 6:04:30 AM

 
cwbates says:
 Your photos are beautiful. I was thinking though, I'm not sure if you should say "Homeless Rebecca" or "Homeless Joe" or whoever as if it's their name or something. I think it would give them more dignity if you just used their names, instead of what they are. Just like I wouldn't call you "Home-Dweller Stoneth." You are a photographer, but you are a human being with a name, more essential to your identity than whether or not you live in a house or on the street. Just a thought.

...posted 11/18/2006 5:42:25 PM

 
A.Denomay says:
 Love it!!! His face structure is unique! :O
& the PS work you applied is simply perfect!

...posted 11/18/2006 2:49:00 AM

 
Kenny and Steve says:
 I don't recollect whether any of your photos has generated as much online discussion as this. As usual, the photo is amazing and the story touching. Have any of these photos changed how I live my life or where my residual income goes? No. But I already contribute to charitable causes, including one group - www.mac-v.org - which helps to house veterans, so I don't feel bad about not doing more.

Having a family member in the mental health profession for many years, I know that many of these people have psychological issues, which cripple their ability to straighten out their lives and live more 'normal' existences. The state of health care in this country simply sucks! Imagine how much better all of our lives would be, if those of us who can afford health care, paid less and those who cannot afford it today, were covered. There is only one excuse for the poor and homeless being without healthcare, which might address their issues and make them productive citizens: a lack of will on the part of certain politicians and a fear that the cost would be too great to individuals or to our society.

I wonder what would be so bad of a society, which finds itself with everyone being treated for their health issues and no one living on the streets unless they make the choice to do so... Bah!

Your photos do move me and clearly others. I think the work is fantastic, even if none ever make it into my art collection. Thank you for bringing these faces into our lives and making us think!

Steve

...posted 11/17/2006 8:54:35 PM

 
Museum of Dirt says:
 Personally...
Homelessness is in itself a major issue.
As is Poverty.

But one issue, many of us seem to overlook, and which governments seem to ignore / put in the 'too hard basket', is the issue of chronic Mental Illness. In most cases, poverty / mental ilness go hand in hand.
Yes, we need to look these people, the ones on the streets in the faces - even vicariously through photos like these - and we need to be empathic and compassionate towards them, and yes we need to feed, clothe and house them.
We also need, desperately, to address mental Health/Illness.
I am writing from Australia here, and even i know that the percentage of people in the criminal system with chronic mental illness in the US is well over 50. Yet 20 % of us on average struggle with Mental Illnes at some stage, mostly deppression and or anxiety, which once treated, leaves fore-ever.

I have chronic mental illness. No, luckily I am not in the criminal justice system, but I do have trouble keeping jobs.
Maybe this lady had a supervisor at her workplace who was accommadating of her condition; maybe it wasn't manifest yet - till the hard times hit. Maybe her unemployment sent her into a depression, which, because of her financial position, she can't afford to treat.
Again, I am lucky here, in Australia, to have subsidised general health-care, and heavily subsidised medication. Without either, I could not afford this basic treatment. I'm not going to go into the state of our Mental Health system here and now, I'll just say that it lacks drastically funding and resources. Without the basic care I get, and the understanding parents I have, I too would be out on the street.

In all countries, not just the US and Australia, we have to look at WHY people are on the streets and address that problem. And I can guarantee, that the lacking Mental Health Care systems, while not the only cause/problem, is one that should be of utmost priority to us as individuals and as societies. And we must push our respective governments to increase funding in these areas. THEN, and only then, can we work seriously towards truly eqitible societies, and not have people tragically living on the streets like this lady, and others in Tom photographs.


On the point of whether or not Tom should be photographing these people and posting the photos on Flickr or his website?
Well, look at the dialogue here, then make up you minds.

thank you, and respect,
Vinnie

...posted 11/17/2006 1:15:07 AM

 
lindes says:
 seabam: a couple of questions/points for you:

(1) Isn't it possible that both points are true? She's homeless because of some sort of mental illness and because she lost her job? And how does one draw the line, anyway? Perhaps losing her job and not being able, at the time, to find a new one led her to mental illness, rather than the other way around. And/or perhaps some minor mental "illness" was present from the start, and made it tougher to get a job. What if that's so? There could easily be a case where one had difficulty getting and/or maintaining a job that, when in it, they did a perfectly good job of doing. Why, in such a case, should they end up homeless? And anyway certainly you can imagine that she would have a tougher time getting such a job now, without the benefit of any recent jobs to get references from, or perhaps of a clean set of clothes and a good shower, or... I hope you see my point(s) here; I'm sure they could be phrased better, but I'm not sure I know how to do so.

(2) Yes, those of us in any major city (just in the U.S.? I don't know) can open our door and see homeless people. Do we, though? I think many of us walk on by without looking, without... "seeing". With photos like this, though, we stop, and we look. I have thoughts on why that might be, but I'll leave them as a thought exercise. Somehow, though, I think many of us find that we (a) can look at these photos more easily than we can look at the actual people, (b) can "see" the people better when we look at these photos then when we pass people on the street, and (c) are more likely to "see" people out there in the real world from having "seen" them in the photos: some say we cannot see what we don't already expect to see; here, we see a photo, which we were expecting, but that opens the door to seeing more, which we can then see out in the world where we wouldn't have seen it before.

I know that the way I look at the world, and the people out in it, has been changed somewhat by having looked at Tom's photos. I expect it will change more, gradually, over time. (So, Tom: thank you.)

...posted 11/16/2006 11:19:38 PM

 
notnA says:
 powerful!!!

...posted 11/16/2006 11:17:55 AM

 
seabam says:
 Your talent as a photographer is amazing. That's clear. I have a hard time though believing this story, although it may very well be that that's what she told you. But the data indicates that people who find themselves chronically homeless tend to be mentally ill. There has been work out there over the last 10 years for accountants. Accountants, as a group, also tend to have stable lives with family and friends; support systems who give people who do temporarily lose their jobs, the ability to get back on their feet. Meaning, that this woman most likely isn't homeless because she lost her job and couldn't find another one. Most likely this woman is homeless because she suffers from some sort of mental illness(es).

Although these photos are really great photos, I just don't quite understand people's reaction to them. If you live in any major city in the U.S. you can open your door and look right at these people without having to see them in a photograph. Are they still so beautiful, as the average person walks right on by when they are on the stree?

There's a documentary about a war photographer. He won a Pulitzer. I can't remember its title. He took a picture of an emicated five year old in Africa with a buzzard over his or her shoulder, waiting to zoom in on the kill. That documentary raises many ethical questions about artistic subject matter that I believe also relates to this work.

...posted 11/16/2006 2:12:31 AM

 
niklens says:
 powerful portrait.....!!!!

...posted 11/15/2006 10:15:39 PM

 
./Eli says:
 54??

amazing.
just great.

...posted 11/15/2006 9:46:49 AM

 
darkenergy777 says:
 Wonderful composition and lighting. Excellent work.!!
Seen in the B&W pool.

...posted 11/15/2006 7:13:04 AM

 
Buddha's Ghost says:
 Riveting! Very sad.

...posted 11/15/2006 5:50:33 AM

 
SkyShaper says:
 doesn't get better !!!! wow

...posted 11/15/2006 4:21:37 AM

 
48x48 (noémi) says:
 Tom, thanks again for responding. btezra, too.
I did read your artist's statement before I wrote to you. Spent a bit of time on your site, actually. And I respect very much what you have to say and that you are very effective in getting awareness for this cause. Again, I apologize for my speculation. Perhaps to actually make a point of telling people on your site that the proceeds (or a portion thereof) from prints sold will be going to a helpful organization, would improve sales. Knowing that, I am sure viewers would be even more motivated to buy your prints. It's a beautiful way to marry your vision with helping the cause. I am not criticizing in the least bit the actual photographing and social documentation - I think that is a very important way to increase social consciousness. I just start questioning photographers' intent when they, for one, are not honest with their subjects about their intent to show these portraits publicly, and two, when they use these images for personal gain in popularity and/or monetary profit. And, without a doubt, I am sure there are a handful of photographers out there like that. I know I've met at least one. Perhaps that's what's decreased my optimism about it.
Nonetheless, respect.

...posted 11/14/2006 10:12:24 PM

 
btezra says:
 "The sad truth of it is, though, as far as I have seen, is that most people will stop, look, make note of the characters, the intriguing and striking details, share a few profound words of "compassion" and then move on with their lives. In the end, the disadvantaged people on the street become not much more than markers in our consciences, almost like warning signs on cigarette boxes"

I completely understand why .noémi. or anyone would think just that, but as someone who shoots social documentary street portraiture quite a lot I can assure you that images, such as Tom's or mine, can push someone to actually do something positive and help influence change. case in point, Don's reaction to an image I posted and his subsequent epiphany to the Light of Life Mission here in Pittsburgh. I quote him as he commented on this image of Larry I took:

"Craig, I thank you for these photos. Today it helped me get off my ass and to quit feeling sorry for myself, and to do something productive to help. While I am certain there are other charities that support the local homeless, due to my proximity to
The Light of Life I donated there today, just now, and truly a sadness that had been with me today was lifted. Thanks again for your care of the less fortunate and your ability to capture their plight in such a humane way."


.noémi., I'd hope you see the optimism expressed through Tom's work, through mine or anyone who is out meeting someone new on the street, speaking to them, taking the time to listening and then asking for a portrait to accompany the experience...for it's through images and stories such as Rebecca's above and the hundreds of others documented and expelled through a forum such as Flickr that people finally can wake up or realize that each of us are connected...

...posted 11/14/2006 9:38:48 PM

 
ggiggs says:
 with beautie comes sadess

...posted 11/14/2006 8:56:50 PM

 
stoneth says:
 .noémi. i've only been doing the gallery thing for a few months, so it's in process. as indicated, the intent is to build a sustainable engine to fund the org... but awareness, "consciousness" and "compassion" are not insignificant and DO lead to good; one person at a time; and through each person differently. small changes in perception cascade. and for those who wish to do more, but don't know how; providing a mechanism to channel personal compassion can lead to even greater impact.

perhaps you read the statement:

"i photograph people who skirt the edges of things; people whose connection to the broader flow is murky or obscured. mistaken as more, less or different than they are; they aren’t really seen and don’t really belong. that’s everyone sometimes; but some more often. i try to establish a line for a moment. i hope to connect. and i see the most beautiful and the most heartbreaking things."

"to my thinking, the original human trauma is our separation. we are too close not to need each other; and too far to trust each other. we rely on dubious senses and clever devices to interact; but we are alone in our thoughts. lonely, insecure and uncertain; we pair, we group, we associate. we try to belong and we seek to exclude. we form bonds by geography, religion, economy and otherwise. but it is all precarious. we come together and we drive apart."

"and we climb our ladder. we step away from those who don’t belong and help those who do. we are connected rung by rung – though less and less – as we push and pull. but some do not climb; and below, the earth is littered with them. they fit too poorly. they stand apart. they stand without. "

"and what of them; these ones who don’t belong or who are excluded; who don’t fit or don’t try? is there nothing they value? is there nothing of them we value? i count it as a measure of our ignorance, the depth of poverty in the world. it’s a glaring marker to how far we have not come. yet it has also driven our advance; on less fortunate backs and against less fortunate fate. "

"but is there really no connection there? does such fate – whether choice or circumstance – speak nothing of us? tell me we do more than advance in place; with so many left behind. or promise me we can do better. say we can reflect ourselves; us and them... that we can see the ways we overlap and distinguish the ways we grow apart. and pledge that we can learn; to fit all of our misshapes; to reward value beyond charity and beyond the marketplace; to be better to each other; to be better ourselves. and promise me it could be a better world. or tell me we are at our best."

...posted 11/14/2006 7:32:15 PM

 
48x48 (noémi) says:
 Tom - I understand. thanks for your response. It's apparent that you do get the attention of people with your social documentary, and that can certainly be seen as a positive step in raising social consciousness. The sad truth of it is, though, as far as I have seen, is that most people will stop, look, make note of the characters, the intriguing and striking details, share a few profound words of "compassion" and then move on with their lives. In the end, the disadvantaged people on the street become not much more than markers in our consciences, almost like warning signs on cigarette boxes - "don't let yourself get to this", and on a distant level of liability, a marker as to how selfish we are. And on an artistically expressive platform such as this, they become not much more than a medium on a canvas and, at most, a momentary inspiration for viewers to dig deep and extract something profound from their thoughts. Your words, though, they make a virtuous endeavour to push viewers to see these faces as something beyond just being an intriguing medium on a canvas. I trust that the monetary profit you make from selling your prints goes back into helping these people, since you seem very passionate in your intent to impact improvement on their lives. If not, well, then... what can I say? If I was a homeless person who you had shot without revealing your intent to exhibit and sell, and if I was walking past your gallery and caught a glimpse of my own face in a portrait on the wall with a price tag on it, I think the irony of the situation would crush me. Since you've left that part of my question unaddressed, and since nowhere on your site does it say that the profit goes to any sort of charity or social betterment fund, I am only left to speculate. Forgive me if I am wrong. I actually hope that I am wrong and sincerely apologize if I am.

...posted 11/14/2006 6:08:14 PM

 
LucaPicciau says:
 What a beautiful, beautiful shot!

An instant one of my faves!

...posted 11/14/2006 4:51:37 PM

 
stoneth says:
 .noémi.: it depends. honestly i try as much as possible not to be a disrupting event; which is to say i try to minimize myself. i try to maintain the moment (despite injecting myself into it). i don't monologue about my hopes and my intent. i try to focus on folk's experiences and their lives and their motivations and their hopes. and i try to meet them wherever they are and commiserate. but we usually start with a question as to why i want to take a picture. it's usually the eyes, or the face, or the personality, or otherwise. and i say so, whatever it happens to be. and usually we get to me being a photographer doing a series about people on the street. sometimes we get to exhibitions and such. so anyway, the top question i always get from people viewing my photos has always been "what can i do." so my hope has been to create a sustainable mechanism for doing something actionable (www.tomstonegallery.org) with photography as an engine. and my intent is to impact improvement in people's lives.

...posted 11/14/2006 4:30:43 PM

 
48x48 (noémi) says:
 hello. found this image on the explore pages today - jumped right out at me - fantastic image. I have seen your work many times. strong documentary, I must say. I am always very curious, though, about work such as this - and this is a sincere question, not just for the sake of stirring anything up. Do you tell the people on the street who you talk to and photograph that you intend to post these images of them on a public forum? I also notice that these images of the homeless are being sold on your website. Does the income you make from these photos go directly back to the people who help you generate such an income by lending their faces and souls (hopefully consciously) to your art?

...posted 11/14/2006 3:13:57 PM

 
ronWLS says:
 Tom - As always another powerful image!

...posted 11/14/2006 7:05:15 AM

 
tEdGuY49® says:
 great image

...posted 11/14/2006 2:43:22 AM

 
Karl L Emmett says:
 These portraits are gut wrenching! It's difficult to see what the end result of these photographs are. Does their plight and life cicurstances add gravity and worth to your photographs. In which case is that exploitation? Or are you helping them or helping to change this problem in some way by taking these photos?

I'm not sure either way. But they are powerfully affecting. Especially with the stories beneath them.

Cheers

Karl

...posted 11/14/2006 2:21:20 AM

 
sakura love says:
 another strong image

...posted 11/14/2006 1:46:12 AM

 
Mc Shutter says:
 Thanks, Tom.
She's only one of thousands with similar, respectable backgrounds who have been dealt the challenge of adversity.
Not all homeless people put themselves there.
Unfortunately, it takes their personal determination to come back from it --- no one's going to do it for them.

...posted 11/14/2006 1:22:34 AM

 
J_B - Johnny B says:
 Tom, once again you have captured another soul on a journey non typical of what our minds could ever comprehend. I pray for warmth for rebecca and a peace that only she can find. I hope others can help her in this endeavor.

j

...posted 11/14/2006 1:02:51 AM

 
sMacshot says:
 Her face reminds me of "grandma" on The Waltons. Jeepers, that story. I feel that could happen to anyone in this country. Just awful that it has to be.

...posted 11/13/2006 11:29:59 PM

 
Esther17 says:
 this photo and your accompanying story brought tears to my eyes. such sadness, and a superb and haunting capture.

...posted 11/13/2006 11:20:36 PM

 
TjF Photography says:
 Excellent Catch!...To me it looks like the Face of Death.

...posted 11/13/2006 10:34:39 PM

 
coldmountain says:
 I keep coming back to this shot. I'm slightly lost for words, but can say that I think your work is superb. Respect.

...posted 11/13/2006 8:10:55 PM

 
SicEmRex says:
 The best kind of photograph - one with an important story to tell. Evocative and moving.

...posted 11/13/2006 7:10:01 PM

 
J.H.C. says:
 I am speechless at you how you have captured people in so many of you photographs. Clap clap, well done!!!!!!

...posted 11/13/2006 6:16:25 PM

 
Joy is a Joy says:
 it makes me wonder, i want to know, what she was in the middle of saying when she said this....and where her family is. ""unprotected. she seems resigned to a losing battle." you may be as good of a writer as you are a photographer. :)) "and moves away from the season's passing throng..." yes, the throng so intent on procuring more things that they don't really need when there are those who are very much in need.

...posted 11/13/2006 5:36:23 PM

 
giftsketcher (a.k.a. possum4all) says:
 My heart breaks from the power of your photography....it's motivation for me to try to make a difference in the world. Some how, some way.

...posted 11/13/2006 5:29:21 PM

 
freakdog says:
 Amazing shot.
Very intense.

...posted 11/13/2006 4:29:40 PM

 
StormyinGA says:
 Lord. This little bit of a woman is only a few years older than me. I am stunned. One's station in life is like a lottery itself. Sad... in fact, beyond sad. I wish her well. I hope she finds a warm bed.

...posted 11/13/2006 4:04:29 PM

 
chris spira says:
 wow. reminds me of munchs´ painting "the scream".
very impressive.

...posted 11/13/2006 3:41:14 PM

 
desslofy says:
 a very moving photo

...posted 11/13/2006 3:24:06 PM

 
-kÇ- says:
 aaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh!

...posted 11/13/2006 3:06:23 PM

 
adwriter says:
 This is heartbreaking. Amazing photo and description.

...posted 11/13/2006 3:02:17 PM

 
* Ahmad Kavousian * says:
 Fabulous

...posted 11/13/2006 2:40:05 PM

 
Mario.com says:
 whoa!
so good

...posted 11/13/2006 2:30:18 PM

 
azli jamil - have mysterious illness :-( says:
 You just made me scared...

...posted 11/13/2006 2:24:37 PM

 
Carlos Ferguson says:
 very powerful image!

...posted 11/13/2006 2:16:15 PM

 
WomanChild says:
 This will haunt me...her story, her face....like a kick in the gut.

...posted 11/13/2006 1:58:22 PM

 
~BranchDesign says:
 WOW. She is so sunken. I feel for her. My heart would break everytime I took a photo....I'd probably go broke too.

Great photo

...posted 11/13/2006 1:52:42 PM

 
ed's point of view says:
 powerful image, which, as others have mentioned, reminds me of Munch's The Scream... sad story.

...posted 11/13/2006 1:51:38 PM

 
dr_mike says:
 your portraits, as I always say, simply leave me breathless. I don't know how you do this, but you're great, and that's all.

...posted 11/13/2006 1:27:04 PM

 
Stox - Ideas Playground says:
 amazing expression !

...posted 11/13/2006 1:09:13 PM

 
Bellechique says:
 poor lady

...posted 11/13/2006 1:07:43 PM

 
original_ann says:
 Her story.... frightens me. How many degrees of separation are there between any of us and Rebecca?
Her image reminds me of Van Gogh's The Scream....

...posted 11/13/2006 12:58:00 PM

 
kathalijne says:
 another beautiful portrait and a moving story. I am glad you're around to document all these amazing stories. And yes, the image is reminiscent of Munch's the scream

...posted 11/13/2006 12:37:30 PM

 
Museum of Dirt says:
 Again...
Speechless.

...posted 11/13/2006 12:34:12 PM

 
Brinas mom says:
 Bless you for bringing us these stories. They illustrate just how fragile life can be. I can only imagine what she was like as a young working woman, alive and vibrant......and now she looks much older and worn than her 54 years deserve. You do such a service for bringing the humanity of these people to us all, and I for one (and I'm sure I'm not alone) salute you for it.

...posted 11/13/2006 12:14:09 PM

 
l . k . t says:
 Absolutely stunning, as always.

...posted 11/13/2006 12:00:56 PM

 
carf says:
 The entire story can be read and felt in her face, which you have captured so well.

...posted 11/13/2006 11:57:55 AM

 
*clairity* says:
 An exceptional portrait.

...posted 11/13/2006 11:50:26 AM

 
santa&binder says:
 Schiele -----munch......

...posted 11/13/2006 11:16:58 AM

 
Therapystudio says:
 I think this is one of your strongest shots

...posted 11/13/2006 11:14:07 AM

 
AlexRan says:
 I've seen her in the tenderloin before. She really does look like a ghost. I'm a big fan of your portraits because I see some of these folks daily and I wish I could do more for them. When I see someone on the street that you've shot It makes me smile. Your pictures/stories have given them their humanity back..much more than I could ever give them by tossing my spare change into their cup.

...posted 11/13/2006 10:56:18 AM

 
mag.m says:
 you have a gallery of tremendously expressive, powerful and moving portraits!
great work!

...posted 11/13/2006 10:56:12 AM

 
Diana Bodea says:
 wonderfull portrait, so expressive, well done!

...posted 11/13/2006 10:33:52 AM

 
Modest and Jill says:
 Awesome portrait

...posted 11/13/2006 10:17:22 AM

 
Eliza Beth says:
 superb portrait - it is interesting but sad to hear her story. great strength in her face.

1-2-3

...posted 11/13/2006 9:53:04 AM

 
u c c r o w says:
 great....reminds me the painting "the scream"..

...posted 11/13/2006 9:52:11 AM

 
DanMaudsley says:
 Wonderful image and interesting story. I feel a lot more must have happened to leave a 54 year old accountant out on the streets. Surely she would have received a hefty redundancy and now, at 62, a pension? But my goodness doesn't she look a lot older than that.

...posted 11/13/2006 9:48:21 AM

 
altamash says:
 powerful!

...posted 11/13/2006 9:25:09 AM

 
mekron says:
 Fabio Sabatini is right. It's Stoneth brilliant Interpretation of Munch's Scream.
Touching shot and story.
Thank you Stoneth.

...posted 11/13/2006 9:16:02 AM

 
Rainer Jacob says:
 Hard stuff . There are a lot of pictures on flickr you want to see but some you have to see.

...posted 11/13/2006 9:10:00 AM

 
george-v says:
 Beautiful story and portrait. I just saw your work in 1-2-3 and made me look at your stream for the first time. Amazing set of images!! Such sad and touching images... I am glad that you do it with such respect.

...posted 11/13/2006 9:09:47 AM

 
Tous les noms sont déjà pris... pfff... says:
 A character from Jerome Bosch !
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

...posted 11/13/2006 9:09:08 AM

 
txiribiton says:
 downsizing...

...posted 11/13/2006 8:53:06 AM

 
mr clearview says:
 i am speechless.
the picture, the story and the woman make me say...............

seen in my contacts

...posted 11/13/2006 8:48:36 AM

 
TobiTobi ( now www.ipernity.com/home/tobitobi) says:
 incredible image and touching story.
Wish her the best!


--
Seen in my contacts' photos. (?)

...posted 11/13/2006 8:37:48 AM

 
Baala says:
 this is a sad story. is there no place for our grands in this world?

...posted 11/13/2006 8:35:07 AM

 
Glauka[deleted] says:
 ╒═════════╣╠═════════╕
This Masterpiece would deserve to appear in :

" ╠Art Libre-Free Art-Arte Libre-Freie Kunst-invited pix only╣ .

tag with : "ArtLibre" and consider to join us :o)

"La photo, c'est un instant saisi, le plus fort, le plus touchant, le plus douloureux."

[ CHAHDORTT DJAVANN ] Iranian novelist and anthropologist
╘═════════╣╠═════════╛

...posted 11/13/2006 8:34:07 AM

 
Glauka[deleted] says:
 My friend... what you shows, what you tell...
Thanks for sharing those images and stories.
This picture es a drama, is art, pure art.

--
Seen in my contacts' photos. (?)

...posted 11/13/2006 8:33:01 AM

 
btezra says:
 speechless.

...posted 11/13/2006 8:28:49 AM

 
kelco says:
 amazing image, moving story. so sad that there are so many similar stories for you to document, but I'm glad that you do.

...posted 11/13/2006 8:24:18 AM

 
Levan Kakabadze (tabu) says:
 gat tait!

...posted 11/13/2006 8:15:48 AM

 
lewishamdreamer says:
 I'm regularly moved by your portraits and your words. There is something here which again sets you apart from everyone else - you seem to have an extraordinary empathic ability which you can channel directly into your work. It is a gift and here in particular you've blown me away. I will always look up to you.

...posted 11/13/2006 8:13:58 AM

 
Alexandre Aybes says:
 Once more, a beautiful photo, and such a sad story… :(

...posted 11/13/2006 8:10:59 AM

 
quebon2 says:
 What a heartbreaking shot and story. Hope she found some shelter.

...posted 11/13/2006 8:10:29 AM

 
s a i n t says:
 Wow wow wow...

...posted 11/13/2006 8:09:32 AM

 
Fabio Sabatini says:
 impressive. she looks like a munch's subject.
greatly done!

...posted 11/13/2006 8:07:54 AM

 

.
separator